Home / Blog / Time capture

Audit a timekeeper's block-billing pattern before the client does

A practical review that finds reconstructed or over-broad time entries before they reach a client guideline dispute.

Legal Billing Assistant Editorial Team · Published · 9 min read

Editorial illustration representing Audit a timekeeper's block-billing pattern before the client does
Table of contents

Define what counts as a block entry

A block entry combines several tasks into one time record without separating the time spent on each. Some blocks are legitimate, such as a hearing that covers several issues in one continuous session. Others hide a day of work behind a vague description. Define the threshold the firm will review, such as any entry over four hours or any entry with more than one task verb.

Write the definition into the review guide with two clear examples. Include a boundary case, such as a deposition preparation that spans several documents but is one continuous task. The reviewer needs a consistent rule before looking at individual timekeepers. A definition that changes per matter will not produce a fair result.

Pull a sample across timekeepers and matters

Sample across timekeepers, practice groups, and matter types rather than focusing on one person. Include entries that were already billed without a client question, because the absence of a complaint is not proof of quality. Draw the sample before reading the narratives so the selection is not biased toward the suspicious. Record the sampling rule and the population so another reviewer can repeat the selection.

Stratify the sample by entry length and by task type. Long entries and entries with several verbs are more likely to need a closer look. Report the number of entries and the number of timekeepers behind each result. A pattern based on one person is a coaching issue, not a firm-wide finding.

Compare the block to the underlying notes

Ask for the contemporaneous notes, drafts, and calendar entries that support the block. Compare the time recorded with the work product and the meeting times. A block that claims eight hours of document review should have a produced document or a clear work trail. If the note is missing, record the gap rather than assuming the worst.

Check whether the block combines work from different days or different matters. A single entry that spans a weekend may be a reconstruction. Look for language that describes the outcome rather than the activity. The comparison should be factual and repeatable by a second reviewer.

Look for patterns that suggest reconstruction

Repeated round numbers, identical daily totals, and entries written in one sitting can suggest that time was reconstructed later. These signs are not proof, and a timekeeper may have a legitimate explanation. Use them to decide where to look next, not to reach a conclusion. The review should distinguish a pattern from an accusation.

Compare the entry dates with the system audit trail when the billing software keeps one. A batch of entries created on the same day for work performed weeks earlier deserves a question. Ask for the source record before drawing a conclusion. Document the answer with the sample.

Ask for a contemporaneous explanation

Send a short request that names the entry and asks for the supporting record. Avoid a general request for an explanation, because it invites a narrative written after the fact. Ask for the calendar item, the draft, or the note that existed at the time. Set a reasonable deadline and copy the supervising attorney.

Record the response and whether it changed the entry. If the explanation is credible, close the item and note the evidence. If it is not, escalate to the billing manager and the responsible attorney. Do not negotiate the entry in a private message that leaves no record.

Correct the entries before the prebill

Correct the narrative, split the block, or remove the unsupported time before the prebill is released. Record the change and the reason in the matter file. A correction made after the client sees the invoice is harder to explain and may require a credit. The earlier the fix, the more options the firm has.

Recheck the corrected entry against the source record. Confirm that the new narrative still supports the fee and that the time total is accurate. If the correction changes the invoice amount, update the client-facing summary. The correction should leave a clear trail, not erase the original record.

Report the pattern without ranking people

Report the findings by entry type, matter, and timekeeper group rather than as a public ranking. The purpose is to improve the record, not to shame individuals. Share the aggregate pattern with the billing manager and the practice group leader. Discuss individual cases privately with the supervising attorney.

Include the entries that were well documented so the report shows the full picture. A report that lists only failures can discourage the behavior you want. Note the examples that show a clear task, a matching source, and a reasonable time. Use them in the next training session.

Change the entry guidance and recheck

Update the entry guidance with the examples from the review. Add a prompt for the source record and a short list of task verbs. Ask the timekeepers to use the new guidance on the next cycle. A guidance change is more durable than a one-time correction.

Recheck a small sample after the change to see whether the pattern improved. Compare the same measures and the same sample method. If nothing changed, the problem may be workload or staffing rather than guidance. Report that possibility honestly and involve the practice group leader. A short follow-up sample is enough to show whether the guidance reached the people who write the entries.

Common questions answered

Is block billing always improper? No. A continuous task that genuinely spans several activities can be described in one entry. The problem is an entry that hides separate tasks or cannot be supported by a source record. Review the substance, not the format alone.

Should the client be told about the audit? Tell the client only if the review changes an invoice or reveals a guideline issue that affects them. The internal audit is a quality control process. Share the corrected record and a brief explanation when a change is needed.

What if the timekeeper refuses to provide notes? Escalate to the supervising attorney and the billing manager. The firm cannot support the entry without evidence. Document the request and the response before deciding whether to remove the time.

Authoritative sources

These public references inform the operating questions in this article. They do not replace legal, ethics, privacy, financial, or client-specific advice.

  1. American Bar Association Model Rules of Professional Conduct

Put the guidance to work

Choose one recurring billing workflow, identify its authoritative source records, and name the owner who reviews exceptions. We can help turn that boundary into a focused support role.

Discuss your workflow